4 Ways Big and Carrie’s Relationship Is Different Than Reality | Thought Catalog
Jun 9, And he never said his own name either, like when leaving an . Perhaps the writers decided that Carrie and Big's relationship was more about. John James "Mr. Big" Preston is a recurring character in the HBO series Sex and the City, Carrie agrees and thus begins their on-again-off-again relationship. he is dating treats him in a fashion similar to the way Big has treated Carrie: at. Jul 21, 4 Ways Big and Carrie's Relationship Is Different Than Reality “You can drive down this street all you want because I don't live here anymore.
They break up repeatedly, over the course of two years for those reasons, before Big marries a gorgeous twenty-six-year-old socialite and Ralph Lauren employee named Natasha Bridget Moynahan after dating her for only five months. This hurts Carrie, as she wonders why he could take steps with Natasha that he refused to take with Carrie. It becomes obvious later that Mr. Big had simply skipped many of the important emotional steps before marriage, many of which he had definitely, if slowly, taken with Carrie, creating the problems of distance and unavailability between Big and Natasha, which Carrie had so feared in their own relationship.
Within seven months of his marriage, he begins to chafe at his matrimonial bonds and pines for Carrie; he initiates an affair with her. Carrie, who is in a committed relationship with Aidan Shaw at the time, feels guilty but continues to see Big.
The affair continues until Natasha comes home unexpectedly and discovers Carrie fleeing—half dressed—from the marital apartment. Natasha trips and breaks her tooth while chasing after Carrie, who ends up taking Natasha to the emergency room. As a result, Carrie ends the affair. Carrie later finds out that Big and Natasha have divorced.
Sarah Jessica Parker Reveals Her True Thoughts On Carrie And Big's Marriage | HuffPost
Big and Carrie eventually become close friends. He relocates to Napa Valleyand they are able to discuss their other ongoing relationships with each other. But their sexual chemistry always remains just below the surface, and their friendship never remains strictly platonic.
After reading Carrie's book, Big begins to understand how much he has hurt her, and he empathizes further when a woman he is dating treats him in a fashion similar to the way Big has treated Carrie: Although it ends up allowing Big to finally get past his inner pain, the comparison is rather crude.
Big grows as an emotional being, changing and evolving as the series progresses, moving past innate pain to suit Carrie's needs better, ostensibly becoming a "better man. He is rarely shown with other males, and when he is, they are usually credited as colleagues or acquaintances.
At one scene he is shown to spend New Year's Eve celebration alone, sitting at a restaurant, but seems to feel comfortable with the situation. Series finale[ edit ] The series finale, "An American Girl in Paris", ties together the loose ends of Carrie and Big's relationship and concludes their long, unconventional courtship.
Absent for most of season six, Big suddenly reappears in Carrie's life near the end of the season, once again at the wrong time. At this point, Carrie has grown tired and frustrated with Big's inconsistency and rebuffs him, but also realizes her behavior towards him has often pushed him away. However, Big is desperate to win Carrie back. The season finale depicts his attempt to reunite with her. The series finale takes place over two episodes in which Carrie moves to Paris with her current boyfriend, Russian artist Aleksandr Petrovsky played by Mikhail Baryshnikov.
She is on her way to her last dinner with the girls before departing for Paris. Big attempts to invite Carrie to dinner and drinks in order to apologize for the way he treated her, only to be turned down. Carrie explains that she is moving to Paris with a man she's in a relationship with. Big asks Carrie when she was going to tell him that she was moving to Paris, a reference to the time earlier in their relationship when Big moved to Napa and almost didn't tell Carrie.
Big teases her about moving to Paris with a Russian and then tries to tell her that she's "The One". Carrie loses her temper and tells Big that she is tired of having him interrupt her life and ruin her happiness for the past six years.
Then she rushes off to meet her friends for dinner, leaving Big alone and confused on the street. When Charlotte stops by Carrie's apartment one day, she hears Big leaving a message on Carrie's answering machine, asking her for one last chance. Charlotte picks up and invites him to meet with her, Miranda, and Samantha. At a restaurant, he asks them if they think Carrie really is happy and if he has any shot of winning her back.
After much deliberation, with Carrie's current situation and her history with Big in the forefront of their minds, Miranda tells him to "go get our girl". Meanwhile, Carrie is distraught and unhappy in her relationship with Aleksandr. She passes Big in his limo on the street in Paris while looking for a cab, but neither of them see each other. Big appears to be searching for Carrie, but the limo rides on and Carrie continues on her way.
Big reappears in Carrie's hotel lobby at just the right moment, as Carrie is squatting down, tearfully gathering up stray diamonds from her broken necklace. She is waiting for a new hotel room, as she just walked out on Aleksandr after a big fight.
4 Ways Big and Carrie’s Relationship Is Different Than Reality
Big comes through the door and as Carrie looks up and sees him, she begins to cry. She explains that everything is a mess and Paris isn't what she thought it would be.
Then she tells Big that Alexandr slapped her during an argument. Big becomes protective and immediately begins climbing the stairs to Aleksandr's room to reprimand him or as he puts it, "kick some Russian ass".
In a desperate attempt to stop him, Carrie trips him and they both fall to the floor, laughing hysterically. They give up seeking out Petrovsky and take a romantic stroll in Paris.
He finally tells her she's the one and she asks him to take her home to New York. They arrive at Carrie's apartment late at night and she asks him if he wants to come up. He answers with a memorable line he used in the first episode "abso-fucking-lutely"which reminds the audience that he is still, in fact, the confident, sexy Big that Carrie has been in love with from day one.
His real name, John, is finally revealed on Carrie's cell phone caller ID after she returns to the city and he calls to tell her he is closing the sale of his Napa estate and returning to New York. Executive producer Michael Patrick King has stated that by never revealing his real name, Big remained "always slightly out of reach" for Carrie, and this plot device is maintained throughout the entire run of the series.
Although we see his name in that final shot, Michael Patrick King makes a point in the DVD commentary that we never hear it spoken in the series. Feature films[ edit ] Sex and the City: The Movie[ edit ] Four years later, Carrie and Big decide to marry, after Carrie brings it up when she starts to feel anxious about her relationship's status.
She loved Aidan for who he was, but she ultimately wanted a man who knew where the finest restaurants were, and which bottle of wine would go best with their meal.
8 Reasons Why Carrie And Big Don't Make Sense (And 8 Why She Should Have Picked Aidan)
Aidan was more of a six-pack of beer boy. Down to Earth was no match for designer suits and a chauffeur-driven car.
She missed out on a kind-hearted hunk who valued what was on the inside. Aidan had a heart of gold and valued intimacy and honesty above all else. He was vulnerable and trustworthy, two things that Big surely was not. Carrie could never get through to Big the way she could with Aidan. Big often had a wall up, making him hard to connect with and trust. Perhaps she wished she could find a man that was the perfect combination of her two great loves.
Of course, that man likely does not exist, but when it comes to important qualities one may want in a mate, honesty is usually at the top of the list. Big could have been lying to Carrie all the time but she just wanted him to want her as much as she longed for him, even if she had to deal with a lack of trust to some degree. Poor Aidan, nice guys always finish last. For so long, she was in love with Big, but he would not reveal how he felt about her.
But Aidan was straightforward with Carrie about his desire for her and was committed to the relationship wholeheartedly. He was in love with everything about her even thought they had gone through some rough patches throughout their relationship. Carrie was always looking for love, but she was hoping it would come from Big in some sort of grand gesture.
She said she loved him too, but Big was always on her mind and in her heart. Carrie must have been over the moon that Aidan loved her like he did, but still, love from him did not mean the same thing to her as love from Big did. It was too bad that the love Aidan had for Carrie was not reciprocated.
He was a romantic man who had plenty of room for Carrie in his heart. She finally decided it was a good idea, but soon regretted the close living quarters. She always wanted to live with Big, or at least get a drawer in his apartment for her stuff. But Big was never ready for such a big change. Carrie was getting cold feet about moving in together and it was evident she made a choice that did not sit well with her.
But if it were Big who wanted to move in, she would have been on cloud nine. But she was still after those things from Big, whether or not she wanted to admit it to herself. Eventually Aidan moved out, and Carrie was all alone yet again. It is a big deal when a guy wants his S. But Aidan put his family right out there on a silver platter. And Carrie freaked out at the thought of it. What did it mean? Was it too soon? Was Aidan rushing things and moving too fast?
Was she ready for all this and did it mean that she was soon going to be part of the Shaw family? Carrie decided not to meet them but at the last minute, she changed her mind and went ahead and met his mother and father.